General Search          Click here for a more Advanced Search
Home   Overview  Links
News
Greenpeace Interactive Map of UK Incinerator Sites


 

Developments since Site was Launched

1999

2000

2001

2003
 

2002
Jan    Feb Mar    Apr May    June   Nov

This page summarises modifications to this Site in 2002

January    5th   21st
February    10th  16th       25th    27th

March    6th      11th       12th      18th       24th
April    7th     8th       14th     28th
May   3rd
June    16th     17th       29th


5th January
    News
        Report
        The Evening Chronicle, Newcastle
        Gagging orders stopped ash probe
        'On the basis of my experience, we do not need an Environment Agency. The EA is clearly a rubber-stamping outfit for the Department of
        Environment, Food and Rural Affairs'
Alan Dalton, former Board Member of the Environment Agency
Report brought to our attention with grateful thanks to Val Barton

21st January
News
    Reports
    The Guardian (16th January 2002)
    Fired Up for Action
     "If you want an incinerator, vote Labour. If you don't, vote Conservative."
        Yet, just one month later, the new Conservative administration .......... reversed its policy

Visitors E-Mails
Please help us...... I am scared for my 2 children.
A most moving e-mail received from a housewife living near the Blue Circle cement plant at Westbury where tyres are to be burned.
A timely reminder of what might await us here if permission is granted for Castle Cement's kiln

'councils intend to sell off prime school sites and re-build the schools on toxic landfill sites. '
Mail from  South Wales.

Byker
Link to the local campaign's  BaN Waste website, added.



10th February
Report
    International Use Of Substitute Liquid Fuels Used For Burning In Cement Kilns
    'French and Belgian cement kilns account for about 90% of the SLF burned in continental European cement kilns. In 1996/97, France used
    262,000 tonnes and  Belgium 200,000 tonnes while seven other countries used 50,000 tonnes between them.'
    CANK Comment:
    We wonder why the German company Heidelberger Zement, Castle Cement's parent company and the second largest producer of cement in
    Europe, so keen to burn SLFs at it's UK plants, including Clitheroe and Padeswood, does not burn them to any extent in Germany.
    Perhaps the German government is more enlightened than the British and won't let them?!

New Link
    World Health Organisation
        Fact Sheet
        DIOXINS AND THEIR EFFECTS ON HUMAN  HEALTH

News
    Letters
    The Evening Leader
    (28th January 2002)
    Kiln saga is 'far from over'

    (4th February 2002)
    Don't let money talk at Padeswood incinerator



16th February

News
The Evening Leader
    Report
        Incinerator plan on hold over fears  (15th February 2002)
        "It would be extremely foolish for politicians not to listen to the people - and to do so would be arrogance of the highest order."

   Letters
        Open invitation to public to visit controversial cement factory (11th February 2002)
        A letter from Tony Allan, General Manager, Production - Castle Cement Padeswood
        'One wonders  whether  the writers would be prepared to call their central heating systems 'gas incinerators'

        In a spin over Castle (15th February 2002)
        'He (Tony Allan) says that recent readers letters were composed of 'spin'.
        Well he should know as he seems to be the master of it.'



25th February
Press Release
    Greenpeace
        Greenpeace Volunteers Shut Down Britains 'Flagship' Incinerator
        'a study published in 2000 showing that children living near incinerators were twice as likely to die of cancers'
          Resultant story in The Guardian (26th February 2002)
           Protesters close down waste incinerator
            'Instead of being reckless with our health the government should replace the south London combined heat and power station and the rest
            of  Britain's incinerators with modern schemes to re-use, recycle and compost our rubbish." '

Report
    Reuters Health - New York
    Tiny Air Pollutants may get into the Blood
    ``Small particles stay airborne for a long time,'' Nemery told Reuters Health. ``These particles may be harmful by themselves or because they
    carry  toxic--or carcinogenic-substances on their surface.''



27th February
    Following on from the Reuters Report - Tiny Air Pollutants may get into the Blood, which we added to the site yesterday:
    Book
   "Particulate Matter: Properties and effects upon health"
    Eds Maynard R L & Howard C V. BIOS Scientific Publishers, Oxford, 1999. ISBN 1 85996 172 X
    As you see, this important book is co-authored by Dr Vyvyan Howard, internationally renowned fetal-toxicopathologist.
    Dr Howard also recommends:
    Philosphical Transactions of The Royal Society, 15th October 2000, volume 358, number 1775, pp 2561-2797.

Press Release
    Greenpeace
        Greenpeace Volunteers defy Baliffs
        "We are 300 feet up and we intend to make it as difficult as we can for the bailiffs to get to us. We are sealing the chimney flues to keep this
        toxic plant closed for as long as possible. Every hour this incinerator remains shut we are protecting people from cancer causing chemicals and
        other poisonous gases."


6th March
PUBLIC INQUIRY RESULT
WELSH ASSEMBLY GRANT PLANNING PERMISSION
    Press Releases

        CANK

        Janet Ryder AM

        Jill Evans MEP
        "Burning toxic waste is not acceptable as it clearly compromises public health. The National Assembly has a duty to adopt a precautionary
        principle, and  should put the onus on the company to prove that their proposals won't put the health of local residents at risk.

A personal observation by the CANK Webmaster



11th March 2002

Article
Daily Telegraph (6th March 2002)
    Blair's arrogance and dishonesty leads me to the Conservatives                               (this link to the Telegraph web site may require you to register to read it)
        Richard Balfe - 23 years a Labour MEP - explains why he has defected to the Conservatives
        "The Byers and the Mittal scandal are symptomatic of a deeper malaise within the Labour leadership - a contempt for Parliament, for
        democracy and, ultimately, for the truth."

A Fairy Story
     'the incineration 'house of cards' might start to crumble'

A Letter to the Prime Minister from a local Labour Councillor
    'either the Labour Party leads the way and harnesses the groundswell that is building over the mismanagement of the disposal of the
    nation's domestic and industrial waste material, or it will pay the price of ignoring it.'

A THOUGHT FOR YOU
    Mr Allan (Castle General Manager, Padeswood) has said that building work will commence within two months.
    BUT the Environment Agency have said that they will not be near issuing any authorisation until the Autumn.
    Would you start a multi-million pound project unless that authorisation, in acceptable terms, were a forgone conclusion?



12th March
A response to Tony Allan's (Castle General Manager) claim in the Flintshire Evening Leader that:
    "We have been here for 54 years and had no impact and there will be no impact from this new development"

           HOW DOES HE KNOW!

    'Are we to trust a man who has allowed his plant to continue to pollute the area with dioxins and then make frivolous claims that fly in the
    face of the best scientific research available from all over the world?'

    'No rules or regulations imposed on the plant by the Environment Agency are going to stop these pernicious chemicals from going directly into
    the local  environment'



18th March
News
    Reports
        Clitheroe Advertiser & Times (14th March 2002)
        Castle Cement faces massive legal action
        'He said he had never come across so many families with two or three children with asthma,'

        New York Times (6th March 2002)
        Soot Particles Strongly Tied to Lung Cancer, Study Finds
        'The bad news is that fine-particle air pollution is even more toxic than we thought before'



24th March
    Local Public Meeting (14th March 2002)
         CANK Chairman's Report
            Initial comments on the Public Inquiry - Inspector's Report:
               'this one stretched the limits of subjectivity to new boundaries'

           In particular
                    The new plant will have a neutral visual impact in spite of being 50% taller and 20 times more bulky than the existing buildings;

                    Castle employees praised for attending but no reference made to the large numbers of local people there;

                    Dr Richard Roberts (by his own admission, not a toxicogist ) CV praised,  but the evidence of DrVyvyan Howard, the eminent and
                    internationally renowned toxicologist, dismissed.

           'that ........ is subjectivity for you!'

         Residents mysteriously locked out.

        Anti-Campaign Flyer left under car windscreens at the meeting:- 'Campaign Allowing New Kiln'
           annotated with CANK comments
                   'It is only those with something to gain: Castle Cement ; local and national government; and their departments,
                    that say there is no danger.'



7th April
News
    Report (Lancashire Evening Telegraph 27th March 2002)
    Health boss wants action on pollution
    After the Padeswood application has been approved, the East Lancashire Health Authority admits for the first time that it has concerns over the health impact of
    the Castle plant in Clitheroe. Coincidence?
    "Given the relatively poor performance of these kilns for emissions of sulphur dioxide and particulate matter, in relation to industry benchmark
    standards, it would be difficult to support the continued use without further remedial measures."


8th April

AMESA
World's First Continuous Dioxin & Furan Sampling System
    Press Release from EMC Environment Engineering (requires Microsoft Office 97 Reader) This is a repeat of the preceding link.
    Certification of long-term sampling system for PCDFs and PCDDs in the flue gas from industrial facilities.(requires Acrobat Reader)
        'In Janaury 2000 the Belgian Government introduced legislation which requires the continuous monitoring of dioxin and furan emissions from
        all refuse incineration plants in Flanders.'

 An end to the unsatisfactory practice of 6 monthly sampling with notice given?

If it can be done in Flanders, then it can be done here.

(With grateful thanks to Dr Vyvyan Howard, Fetal Toxico-Pathologist, Liverpool University, UK)

14th April
Mispelstraat: Living Under the Smoke of a Waste Incinerator
    Report  d/d 7/01 on the health impact of the MIWA - waste incinerator in Sint-Niklass Belgium
    Produced by local medical staff, without any state help, this report is a salutory lesson in the consequences of waste incineration.
A MUST READ for anyone interested in how a local waste incinerator could affect them.

28th April

CANK AGM 3rd May 2002
Starts 7pm at the Penyffordd Institute, and will be followed by a general public meeting during which local MP Mark Tami will be available to answer questions.

Mispellstraat
    Following the addition of this disturbing report on 14th April, we have received a most moving account from Fred De Baere, who lives in the same road as this
    Belgian incinerator. The lack of support from their government is reminiscent of our government's treatment of the Byker scandal.
    Fred's mail is added here in entirety.
    At this moment my daughter of 20 years old, has her periods just two or three times a year, caused by a hormone disruption.
    We detected recently that my son of 16 years old has a neurotic development.

Open Door
    Those local to Padeswood will have received the latest edition of 'Open Door': Castle Cement' 'community newsletter'.
    Once again this company chooses to insult us.
    Whilst extolling the virtues of the proposed kiln in reducing greenhouse and acid rain gases - indeed commendable, NO MENTION is made, yet again, of what
    really concerns everyone here: dioxins (for which there is no safe lower limit); heavy metals and ultrafine particles.
    It is these extraordinarily toxic pollutants that the new kiln WILL PRODUCE and which all available evidence suggests WILL HARM people.
    CANK has received a copy letter from a resident which is posted today and which encapsulates local feeling:
    'we are in the fortunate position of being able to move away from the immediate area which is what we will do once the kiln is completed.'

    Interesting also, that Tony Allan who, as general manager of Castle Cement at Padeswood runs  the worst dioxin polluting cement kiln in the UK and, during his
    tenure, has seen it climb from 11th to 7th worst UK dioxin polluter overall, is to be chairman of the North Wales CBI.
    What kind of message does this give to the local population?

Public Inquiry Report
    Now available on the Internet
    The full Report; Assessors Report; and the Decision Letter are available.
    The Report is lengthy but the Decision Letter gives an overview of the Inspector's and the Welsh Assembly's thinking on this matter.
    Particularly revealing, in the Decision Letter,  are:
        Paras 8 & 11 dealing with health.
        Heavy reliance here on Dr Roberts' superficial and widely critisised health report which relied exclusively on Castle Cement data.
        Note also the use of the word 'material' relating to harmful effect, without any definitions.
        Para 13
        This whole campaign is about the use of hazardous waste yet the Welsh Assembly fully endorses the Inspector's decision not to hear such evidence fully and in
        detail on that issue.

HOW 'INDEPENDENT' IS AN INDEPENDENT PUBLIC INQUIRY?



3rd May
The 119 Questions!  (requires a Microsoft Word Reader)
Following the submission by Castle Cement of its IPPC Application for Padeswood, the Envronment Agency has tabled 119 questions that the company must provide answers to by 1st June. Not only does the breadth and detail of these questions point to an extremely shoddy and superficial initial submission by Castle but also a commitment by the Environment Agency to get this one right, if followed through and properly enforced, with no variations.
CANK will monitor Castle's responses and future correspondence in this vital area and keep you informed.
    In particular, you might like to check out:
    Question
    39            Proposals for upgrading the existing highly polluting  kilns until the new kiln (4) comes online;
    106          Details of proposed continious monitoring
               109  also refers to monitoring stack emissions from the existing kilns
    117         Health Impacts

    Note:(June 2002)
    A CD containing Castle Cement's responses to these questions is available - free - from CANK. Simply E-Mail Us for your copy.



16th June

News
    Report
    The Chronicle, Mold & Buckley Edition (June 14th)
    Factory is critisied over appeal
    'Castle Cement has been accused of holding up measures to cut emissions from its existing Padeswood plant.'

    The Observer (16th June)
    Dark heart of the American Dream
    An excellent article on the effect of combining sympathetic government and big business to the detriment of ordinary people - sound familiar?

Report
    Greenpeace International
    Incineration: The Burning Issue
    An outstanding summary of the implications and concerns surrounding this most controversial issue
    'There may be high tech incinerators but there is no such thing as a non-polluting incinerator.'


17th June
Press Release
    Greenpeace (17th June 2002)
    Construction of New Incinerator Halted by Activists, Government Misleads Public over new Rubbish Burners
    'Even a well-operated modern incinerator that meets the emission limits defined in the Waste Incineration Directive will add to the overall burden
    of persistent  pollutants such as dioxins in the environment.' (Food Standards Agency Nov 2001).


29th June
Liason Committee Resume
    Castle hosted the second meeting on 17th June.
    Their purpose  is to involve and inform the local people of what is happening at Castle Cement ,Padeswood, as they endeavour to bring pollution from the existing
    plant under control and proceed to apply for their IPPC licence for both the existing plant and the planned new kiln.

    A brief but, nevertheless, essential precis of the current situation.
 

IPPC
    Waste fuels form centrepiece of cement firms' IPPC applications (ENDS April 2002)
    but
    [Castle, Rugby & Blue Circle] 'have failed to justify their emissions against the benchmark for the "best available techniques" BAT'

    Castle's Response to the EA's 119 Questions in available on CD. E-Mail us if you would like a free copy.
 

Breast Cancer Clusters may start in Childhood
    'a novel study by geographers and epidemiologists at the University at Buffalo. Where a woman lives at birth and puberty may have an impact on
    her risk of  developing breast cancer later'
    'the possible link between breast cancer and early environmental exposure to potential carcinogens'

Environmental News Service
The Irish Times
Doctors' group warns on unknown risks of incineration (April 2002)
    An excellent article on a group of doctors from Ireland
    'We have a waste problem in Ireland at the moment, but by burning our waste, and thereby reducing the volume, we simply have a different
    problem,.........Incineration is not a solution to anything'

    'we have concerns regarding adverse health effects. There are many types of compounds in our domestic waste, which contain numerous
    chemicals. It does not make sense to burn these chemicals which will combine in the furnace, releasing unknown compounds, whose composition
    and effects we know little about, into the environment.'

Dr Roberts - PLEASE take note!



 
 

 Home
Return to the Main Page

Overview
A quick summary of why there is such concern over the erection of the new kiln

Links
Links to many other web sites dealing with all aspects of this issue

Newsflash
Up to the minute news on developments together with new additions to the Web Site

Your Views
Feedback and Newspaper Cuttings from Local Residents

What Next?
How you can register your opinions with the people that count

For more information, like to add your own views, or if you have any further web links you would like us to include,  please email us at: feedback@cank.org.uk