General Search          Click here for a more Advanced Search
Home   OverviewLinks
News
Greenpeace Interactive Map of UK Incinerator Sites


 

Developments since Site was Launched

1999

2000

2001

2002
 

This page summarises modifications to this Site from 2003

2003
February    6th

2004

May 31st
June 18th
July 4th
August 16th

2005
March    13th

2006
June    11th


6th February 2003

Yes, CANK is still here and very much alive and kicking!. Forgive the inordinate delay in updates but much has been happening:

CANK Health Survey
'When Industry, Public Servants and Local Authorities appear to be arguing that residents do not need to know more about something which has been of intense public interest for the last few years, you can be forgiven for imagining they have something to hide.'

Arnold Woolley, Chairman, CANK
On Sunday, 10th November, CANK delivered Health Questionnaires to 1400 homes in Penyffordd and Penymynydd with a view to obtaining an indication of what substance, if any, there was to continuing anecdotal evidence of clusters of illness in the villages.

To date, a little over 30% of households have responded and the data is being collated prior to going for expert interpretation.

IT IS STILL NOT TOO LATE TO RETURN YOUR QUESTIONAIRE
PLEASE DO SO EVEN IF YOU HAVE NOTHING TO REPORT

The response we have had already is magnificent and sufficent to produce a meaningful conclusion. However, additional replies will only further strengthen any conclusions the experts draw.

This survey follows repeated requests for a Baseline Health Survey of the area being ignored by the authorities. After much vacilating, it is gratifying to see that the Environment Agency have now made a commitment to obtaining a baseline health study as part of their assessment (see Chronicle story below)

We will keep you appraised of the results.

See Also
    Newspaper Report
        The Chester Chronicle (Front Page January 24th)
        1,420 homes in health survey - kiln protest group's delight at response
       'If this kind of survey had been carried out much earlier by the authorities, it would have avoided the cost of an expensive public inquiry and the upset to people living in the area.'
           However:Doubts about the independance of SAHSU (Small Area Health Statistics Unit), to be employed by the EA to carry out a proposed baseline health study

IPPC Liason Meeting
Discussions continue, particularly with regard to the Critical Success Factors that will define the effectiveness of the committee.
On a positive note, Castle report that following installation and trial of a quenching system for the exhaust gases from the existing kilns, dioxin production has dropped to 0.26ng/m3 (average for 12 months - 0.49ng/m3). This compares very favourably with the 2.10ng/m3 for the previous year and the 0.1ng/m3 EU limit is being approached.
Such a shame that this remediation could not have been implemented years ago, and automatically, by the company when they realised their dioxin levels were huge, and without the  public outcry and concerns of the past few years. Such a step would have done much to build the credibility the company now so desperately needs.

A VIABLE ALTERNATIVE TO INCINERATION
        Dr Paul Connett (Professor of Chemistry at St Lawrence University in New York)
        Video:
        Zero Waste: Nova Scotia moving from the Vision to the Reality
           How one Canadian island of a million people has decided to recover as much waste as possible and the realities of the huge success they have achieved.
          A MUST SEE
       An excellent short paper accompanied by an outstanding 30 min video: Nova Scotia: Community Responsibility in Action
          With Paul Connett's kind permission, CANK will provide both free of charge - simply mail us at connettvideo@cank.org.uk with your address.
          Remember, your TV will need to use the UK PAL format to view the video.
          For those with the US NTSC format, please specify and we will endeavour to obtain a suitable copy.

Reports
Health Vacuum in IPPC Guidance(ENDS 320 - September 2001)
    Although a year old, still highly relevant:
    'the health authorities have an undistinguished track record of engaging with environmental matters.'

    'The Agency's lack of competance on environmental health issues has become an increasingly prominant weakness. The regulator has shied away
    from debate on health impacts in contentious cases concerning incinerators and cement kilns.'

News
    Reports
    Dioxins in Babies at 85 times Safety Limit (Independant 17th November 2002)
    'The Government has to decide whether it is going to put the interests of its friends in industry or the health of babies first'
    (Mike Childs, Senior Campaigner, Friends of the Earth)

    New View of Waste The Chester Mail (20th November 2002)
    Announcement of a comprehensive strategy being implemented by the local authorities in Cheshire to minimise waste and drastically increase recycling

    WITH ONLY A PASSING REFERENCE TO 'ENERGY FROM WASTE'

  Cllr Wesley Fitzgerald, Cheshire LGA Waste Task Group Chairman said:
'These are issues which affect all of us and we all have a part to play in bringing about changes which will
benefit the county's quality of life for many years to come.'
WELL DONE CHESHIRE - A GREAT EXAMPLE

    Press Releases
    Autism linked to air pollution (The Sunday Express, 12th January, 2003)
    'Early findings reveal children with developmental brain disorders- all of whom live around incinerator sites'
    "the levels of toxins we have found in these children's blood is frightening."
 

    Paris
    CNIID (21st January, 2003)
    Waste Incinerators provoke the birth of deformed babies
    '"high and significant risk (...) for facial clefts, renal dysplasia, and megacolon".

    Plaid Cymru
    Protesters win incinerator fight
    Councillors reject the plan for a municipal waste incinerator for Wrexham after a huge public outcry. The matter, however, is to be the subject of a Public Inquiry
    next year, so the matter will be decided by the Welsh Assembly in Cardiff

    " I can't possibly support it when there is a risk, no matter how small or how great "
Councillor Ron Davies
    See Also
    Dampener put on incinerator (The Chester Mail - 27th November 2002)

    CANK Comment
    So Mr Burnett, Project Manager of HLC Wrexham believes that, in spite of Wrexham people not wanting his incinerator and Wrexham councillors now refusing to support it,
    the plant will go ahead anyway.
    What does that say of his and his company's concern for the wishes and fears of the community in which they hope to operate.
    Or perhaps he is voicing what he knows already, that the communities opinions carry little weight?!


31st May 2004
News
    Report
    Factory kiln work 'is on schedule' (Flintshire Evening Leader)
        "The new conditioning and pre-heating tower will ensure dust does not escape into the atmosphere"  Tony Allan - Castle Production Director

        Reaction from informed CANK member - Cllr Arnold Woolley
            The company (Castle) seeks to:
                "Move the emissions limit upward for Total Organic Compounds, which are comprised of Volatile Organic Compounds, which, in general are not good news for people
                            or the environment"

CANK Comment
It would seem Mr Allan continues to treat the local population with indifference.
That would be consistant  with his time as General Manager of the Padeswood plant when he presided over the worst dioxin polluting cement facility in the country and  saw it rise from 11th to 7th  worst overall UK dioxin polluter during his tenure.

It is also interesting to note that, since the Public Inquiry,
local pressure on the Environment Agency has resulted in Castle introducing processes which, we understand, have significantly reduced dioxin output.

MR ALLAN COULD HAVE AND SHOULD HAVE DONE THAT YEARS AGO
IF HE REALLY CARED ANYTHING FOR THE LOCAL ENVIRONMENT.

However, if he is serious, perhaps he would now like to undertake to shut the plant down as soon as any dust escapes into the atmosphere from the new kiln?


18th June 2004
Substitute Fuels Protocol
The Environment Agency is proposing that a much wider range of hazardous wastes be burned in cement kilns by lowering the standards that will apply to substitute fuels.

Read of this most disturbing development:
    The EA's Review Document  (requires Acrobat Reader)
    CANK's submission to the consultative process. (requires Microsoft Word Reader)
"the baseline thresholds of 31 substances were INCREASED by factors of ten, one hundred, or even more.  Many of those were VOC’s with seriously damaging effects on health,
     locality, or the global environment."

In Summary:
If this protocol is approved, wastes which previously needed specialised treatment, handling and control, with known health risks emanating from their inappropriate combustion, will now be able to be burned as 'fuel' in cement kilns, regardless of calorific content, and without the stringent disposal requirements that apply to hazardous waste incinerators.

Interestingly, Castle Cement was referring to this new Protocol in their correspondance with the EA long before it's existence had been made known. Is government preferring  the cement industry to the welfare of the local population?


EITHER A WASTE IS HAZARDOUS OR IT IS NOT
If hazardous and it must be burned,
Burn it in a PURPOSE-BUILT incinerator
Where all necessary controls and checks are in place.
WHAT HAS SUDDENLY CHANGED, EXCEPT POLITICAL EXPEDIENT?



4th July 2004

Letter
    To CANK from Cleanaway's Plant Manager, Technical Waste Incineration Plant in Ellesmere Port
       ' In effect, the cement kiln will function as a co-incinerator, but be allowed to operate at lower specifications and standards than purpose-built incinerators.'
        'Cement kilns not being required to undergo the thorough environmental impact assessments ......as is required for purpose-built High-Temperature incinerators.'

    We would urge you to read this excellent letter which encapsulates many of CANKs serious concerns.

   See Also: Cement kiln row re-ignites as substitute fuels set for rapid growth (ENDS Report 2004)

News
    Friends of the Earth Press Release
    Tyre Burning Trial Halted After Emissions Alert
    Environmental campaigners today called for a full public inquiry into a controversial tyre-burning experiment which was suspended after it flouted emission regulations.
    Rugby Cement continues to burn tyres after a failure in a dust collection unit until ordered by the EA to stop."this is specifically forbidden by our permit conditions" (EA spokesman)

RUGBY HAVE A SIMILAR KILN TO THAT BEING ERECTED AT PADESWOOD
IS THIS A TASTE OF THINGS TO COME?

In a related story we understand that Castle Cement in Ketton have suspended the use of Profuel, a plastic and paper substitute fuel,
because the chlorine content of the resultant cement was too high.
Was it the effect on the product and not any impact of excessive chlorine on the local population that stopped the use of the fuel?

CANK Note: In Rugby, there is serious concern in both in the Local Council and in the Primary Care Trust about the health implications of what is being burned in their kiln.

    THIS IN STARK CONTRAST TO OUR OWN LABOUR CONTROLLED COUNCIL WHO APPROVED THE PLANNING APPLICATION
AND
DR ROBERTS, LOCAL AREA HEALTH CONSULTANT IN HIS NOW NOTORIOUS REPORT IN WHICH HE STATED:
'Individuals living in the area of the works are very unlikely to suffer any harmful effects from authorised emissions of any pollutant, including dioxins, from the proposed kiln'

IF THEY ARE WRONG AND LOCAL PEOPLE SUFFER OVER FUTURE YEARS AS A CONSEQUENCE,
WITH ALL THE WARNINGS THAT ARE OUT THERE,
WILL NOT EACH OF THEM HAVE BLOOD ON THEIR HANDS?


16th August 2004

News
    Reports
    Pollutants Cause Huge Rises in Brain Diseases (Observer 15th August 2004)
    "'This has really scared me,' said Professor Colin Pritchard of Bournemouth University, one of the report's authors.
    WWF has named chemical pollution as one of the two great environmental threats to the world, alongside global warming, and is particularly worried about 'persistent and accumulative' industrial
    chemicals and endocrine - hormone distorting - substances linked to changes in gender and behaviour among animals and even children.

Paul Connett - Nova Scotia Recycling Project
                        This extremely important project has received a valuable endorsement - see:
                               A comprehensive, full cost-benefit analysis of the Nova Scotia Solid Waste-Resource Management Strategy
                                          accounting for benefits like avoided greenhouse gas and air pollutant emissions; avoided liability costs; extended landfill life; and
                                          increased employment. It also accounts for the costs of the bottle deposit-refund, tire recycling, and stewardship programs,
                                         and the cost of the extra time needed to sort waste.

REMEMBER - CANK will provide a copy of Paul Connett's video explaining the project, free of charge. Simply mail your request, with your address, to connettvideo@cank.org.uk

House of Commons
                    Early Day Motion 06/07004 expressing concern over proposed variations to The Substitute Fuels Protocol
                    52 MPs, including Flintshire's Mark Tami, sign a motion expressing 'strong concerns about the Environment Agency's proposals to relax the rules
                    on the burning or a broader range of highly hazardous substances in cement plants'

Greenpeace
                  "How to comply with the Landfill Directive without incineration: a Greenpeace blueprint"     (Requries Acrobat Reader)

                      "It is entirely possible to achieve the Landfill Directive targets without using incineration"  (Peter Jones, Director, Biffa Waste Services)
 

E-Mails from:
    Phil - construction worker with Castle Cement
                    "i would like to thank castle cement for it's courageous decision to expand its plant"
    Eric Black, Rhyl South West Central Residents Association.
                    "I have known this area all my life and it (the kiln)  is the most horrendous monstrosity i have ever seen"
                    "Even if that is not bad enough this will have emissions when in use and cannot be anything but dangerous with the
                      most populated region of North Wales in its potential radius."
    Christopher Strangeways, Rother Environmental Group
                    "Heidelberg Cement own and operate a solvent re-processing facility (SRM ltd) in Rye that produces Cemfuel and ProFuel
                      we are always interested to be kept informed of your concerns."


13th March 2005
News
  Reports
        SHUT DOWN - Castle Cement in alert over toxic chemical releases (Evening Leader 4th March 2005)
                   EA    Notice re Castle Suspension        (Click on 'Skip to page content' at the top of the EA page you are taken to.)
CANK COMMENT:    It took 9 months for the EA to react to exceedances which we understand averaged some 27 times the recommended level of  what are
some of the most toxic pollutants known to man and then not on the basis of their own monitoring but on the emissions levels reported by Castle.

11th June 2006
News
    Web Link
EMISSION WATCH
A truly independant monitoring service that is currently watching particulate levels in the areas surrounding the Padeswood Hazardous Waste Co-Incinerator
Browse the graphs and note, especially, the huge spikes seen, generally in the early hours and particularly in Central Penyfordd and Spon Green, areas, historically, most affected by this plant. Early Christmas Morning 2005 (around 5am) is especially interesting!!


 Home
Return to the Main Page

Overview
A quick summary of why there is such concern over the erection of the new kiln

Links
Links to many other web sites dealing with all aspects of this issue

Newsflash
Up to the minute news on developments together with new additions to the Web Site

Your Views
Feedback and Newspaper Cuttings from Local Residents

What Next?
How you can register your opinions with the people that count

For more information, like to add your own views, or if you have any further web links you would like us to include,  please email us at: feedback@cank.org.uk .